Thursday, March 23, 2006

The Swarming Life: Bombay


I saw a lean figure listing forward, in a blue synthetic shirt, walking with a briefcase. He stays in our colony. He was once a skinny kid who lingered on the edges of cricket matches in the park, refusing to play but laughing if someone slipped or got out. Then he became a teenager with awkward rat-fur whiskers and oversized specs. Now he's a man, twenty-something, oxidising day by day, working for a spare parts supplier.

As I walk past him, I think of time, of how his face would broaden into middle age, how his mind would be ready with the harsh practical lessons of ration cards, home loans and vehicle installments. And I pray for him. He hurries, you see, for an auto to the station for a train to a station for a train to a station for a train to a station for a taxi (sharing) to his office gate; and all's reversed in the evening.

I don't know. Maybe he dreams of charging on a wildebeest, African grasses crackling for him, while in thundering drums and ritual vapours a hundred grass-wearing women call out. Maybe.

He also makes me rake up an old uneasiness about this city I live in.

Atticus's beautiful post has got me thinking again about Mumbai. I have always loved the city; to say 'Bombay' in Bangalore had a special charm for me, a glittering metropolitan exoticity of speed. I boasted about the city's gangsters, and lied about film stars walking everywhere in the streets and how we were used to it.

I belong nowhere, but Bombay gives me places I can call my own, in my own quirky ways, in a crowd of a millions. I have walked around Fort in endless, aimless patterns, in the heat of the day, in the dusking glooms, in the solemn yellow daubs of night. Where I pause, letting the eye linger on high Victorian friezes, I sense the heart of this large amoeboid form , and its throbbing, bustling beats. Like blood corpuscles, people hurry, pouring into Fort in the morning, retreating into suburban flats at night. The trains halt in light and shadow, platform after platform, exhaling people, then inhaling them. The trains, the crowds, the floods, the heat, they come and go, and life goes on, and people die, and money flows, and children who travelled with their mothers in ladies' compartents now hang from the doors of men's compartments, chewing one-rupee gum, with slick, straight hair and middle partings, one foot at the door, another at the window, a bright green comb jutting out of the pocket. With heavy, measured wings, Eliot's powerful lines move in my mind:

London, the swarming life you kill and breed,
Huddled between the concrete and the sky
Responsive to the momentary need...

I belong in quieter places, with fewer, simpler, naiver people who won't push you or shriek as they hooligan past each other for a seat when a local arrives. I miss the Bangalore of my childhood, the sounds of sweeping coconut brooms at sunrise, and Suprabhatam on the radio, and women bending at thresholds, their fingers perfect with rangoli. I miss the early morning flower sellers, whom you could call out to if you were a grandmother. Mallige! Baa pa illi. The Mallige seller's name is Mallige. The irulli seller's name is irulli. Alugadde! Baa pa illi. I miss the roads sprinkled with bluebells, and women plucking hibiscus, and the shivering winter cold when you walked slowly, hand in pockets, thinking of your love and the warmth of her face as it moves towards you, an eerie shadow in a lonely street. And crouching men in monkey caps, walking past you, every breath billowing like beedi smoke.

The smell of filter coffee. The thud of a fresh crisp Deccan Herald- which would dwell on bad roads and Gowda-flavoured politics- and then of how Dravid "caressed the cherry with sublime elegance". Retired men with wattled throats, some brisk, some pretending to walk, others huddled under peepal trees for decisions on world affairs. Coffee in tinytot tumblers of steel at one-minute eateries. Vans returning from the wholesale market, piled with fresh bargain vegetables for someone's wedding, and six little cousins craning out of the window.

Damn the IT crowd. Bangalore was much more than them, so much more, and now perhaps the new-found money has cut across the city's throat, like the blade of a swiss army knife, bought in Chicago, sharpened in Chickpet, to leave the city choking in its own blood.

And Mumbai beckons like a mistress, with the leaping of paan on British stone, the blurr of the sweeping crowd like bolts on assembly lines, the guarantee that you will find one eccentric person wherever you look. The Public is everywhere, with a detached tolerance of the stranger: men can walk around, waving happy wands, abusing that traitor of a sky, while couples neck and cuddle. Even a street scuffle gathers but a handful of people, for the rest have a local to catch. And Fort is the place. Rich with the moneyed, rich with beggars, full of bhel and pirated porn, where curators, traders, hawkers, consultants, all arrive and leave as one.

The streets explode before me, with their visual pungency. Tribal families, maroon and green and glass, framed by cooking fumes behind the NGMA bus stop, in the full blast of noon. Beggars rest at ticket counters at Victoria Terminus, stretching out their slender grimy hands. Little girls run after a potbellied trader, carrying babies at their waist; the trader shifts from foot to foot, picking his molars with his finger; the baby shifts from waist to waist, scratching a tiny, lice-infested head. And late at night, near the same counters, with lips of trademark red, prostitutes slowly loop around the crowd, their gaze in searching beams. Outside, other women wait at the subway's entrance, adjusting their tops, bearing college-like bags, for a stare that might mean business. The subway's madness of light and sound and bustle. And urchins crouch behind the station-bridges, bullying each other, sniffing glue. Footpaths fill with men on sheets, scratching as they yawn...

What does one say about Bombay? For all the talk of opportunity, of how anyone can make it big, for all the riot of movement and sound and colour, and all the grime of rain-worn walls, people age quickly here. Their life is measured in yellow train tickets and footpath deals. Bombay takes its routines for granted. As men tumble out and tumble into the choking mouths of local trains, day after day for the thirtieth year, they forget that this is a choice they've made, that there are other, more human ways to live...

Lord, grant me the wisdom. Also grant me a little cottage in small-town Himachal, with a fireplace, and a thousand musty books, and a cup of Darjeeling tea, and a ridiculous troupe of noisy, shiny-nosed kids to teach.

33 comments:

Atticus Finch said...

Hmmm, unspoilt wilderness, musty books and kids to teach... You've taken things straight out of my wishlist :D

Hermit Chords said...

@ Atticus

:))

Maybe it's everyone's wishlist, suspended in the collective unconscious...

Anonymous said...

This is the bestest post I've read in a long long long time.

A million accolades in the guise of Blackberries and delicate china cups wafting of Broken Pekoe..

Hermit Chords said...

@ anonymous

Thanks. I wonder how the world would be if we were all anonymous. It would simplify a lot of life's struggles maybe, we would be free of our egos, our self-images and obsessions with identity, and would function like free impulses in a larger, expanding consciousness, like heaving waves in an ocean, dissolving into one another, history into history.

karmic_jay said...

Great blog, very well written. I can certainlu identify with your thoughts about Bombay. Now that I dont live there anymore, I sort of appreciate the memories (a lot of them reawakened when I read blogs like yours).
I don't miss the place though, the city is a beast just barely in control.

Anonymous said...

the only real bombay I have known is riding the train from navi mumbai to colaba. through water that didn't separate itself from the sky, I looked hard for the horizon. All this through the smell of fish, a blind kid singing, people stare because sometimes, we have this uncanniness of looking like we belong/ don't belong everywhere in this world it seems like.
And then walking thru the Prince of Wales museum for what might have been 6 hours. I had never known this kind of beauty. Slowly walking and absorbing statues, imperfect in that they had been destroyed, faces, paintings, moving from corridor to corridor, through outside to inside, climbing steps, holding the railing. It was like a perfectly made dream and time had no relevance.
I have had moments in Bangalore- like the atrium gallery in alliance francaise- between looking at paintings, I look at the doors, the plumbing lines, beauty has never seemed so complete with ordinary familiarity. Or the library in Max Mueller bhavan, looking at books and touching them, each one of them, there has never been so much sensuousness in an ordinary moment, or café schrolemmer on a rainy day, sipping coffee, it felt like I was living out of context, surrounded by stretched canvas and potted plants.
All cities (in India) have this immediateness about them, they get as close as you allow them to get, kiss you and then go away. And on a blistering summer afternoon, driving from k to d, cursing, honking, getting annoyed at the traffic, I look up at the sky for just a moment. The feathery eucalyptus, the jacaranda assure me that there is love. It is completely unrequited, with all that baggage.
So maybe it is not about Bombay, or Bangalore, or delhi for that matter, or even chandigarh. It is just about these moments in a city, teeming with people, so many faces, that is such a comfort because one is always anonymous.

Hermit Chords said...

@ karmic_jay

:) I'm moving too. I'll certainly miss Marine Drive. But people forget that the waters there, in all that gleam and glitter, are smelly with toxic waste. People love saying, 'Bombay will go on'- but I'm not so sure. I feel the weight of your sentence, 'the city is a beast just barely in control'.

Hermit Chords said...

@ anonymous

There's an intensity about the metropolis that a small town or village can't quite command, isn't there? I'd be happier if I get away, but maybe a little too happy...

Your beautiful note reminds of a quote a friend gave me:

"To each man, a city consists of no more than a few streets, a few horses, a few people. Remove those few and a city exists no longer except as a pain in the memory, like the pain of an amputated leg no longer there." – Graham Greene

What I miss are the bookshops- or maybe I just don't where they are! I've heard of a place called Smoker's Corner but haven't managed to find it. If you know any place for old books in Fort, do let me know.

Bangalore has Premier and Select and Blossoms. Everytime I go there, I wish I had day for each of them.

Ph said...

How lovely is remembering. Especially if it can happen in the reading of a "baa pa, illi". Such a subtle trigger for so much. Thank you.

Nandan said...

Hi Kaushik
Came here via Desipundit. Liked your entry...however, could not really relate with it. Have lived in Mumbai almost all my life and in Bangalore for around nine months. Bangalore, for all its greenery and (comparative) cleanliness, still seems like a small town undecided about itself: should it be a metropolis, or should it be the beautiful hill-station capital.
As for Mumbai, yes, it is dirty, ugly and crazy. But I don't think I will be comfortable living anywhere else in India. It's too much a part of me. And probably, a lot of Mumbaikars will say the same. Again, there are a lot of Mumbais within Mumbai and all of us love a particular Mumbai.

Hermit Chords said...

Hi Nandan,

Certainly. Even the Bangalore here, you see, is only a purified memory. I'm not sure if Bangalore is confused any more though. The hill station city is dead and buried. It's a clogged and crime-ridden, half-formed monster, full of dark spaces and getting on its own nerves. I think space for thr individual is also an issue now.

Mumbai for all its madness has a niche for almost everybody, once you punch your way out of the local and feel your wallet.

Maybe this is a phase every metropolis goes through- the feeling that growth is uncontrolled, that a unique culture's fading away and that something must be done. Here of course we move away from my personal memories into a more structured way of looking at how cities evolve. Any thoughts/links on this would be welcome.

Kaushik

Anonymous said...

Hi Kaushik,
Am a tam bram detached from his relatives, bought up amid tams, gujjus, maharashtrians, mallus et al, here in Bombay ..24 years of bombay is what i have seen, have grown up with the crowd, the trains, the sqaualor and all the other things good and bad.....tho the thing i remember about bombay is that it's home for me.....

Who am i can be answered in hajaar ways, who am i deals with my identity for myself and that my friend is that i am a mumbaiyya....with all its pros and cons...the legacy bombay has left me with is that i can't speak a single language n its entire purity - bombay never demanded me to.....i can be stuck in traffic for hours and not crib, not honk, not get frustrated about it - courtesy mumbai..... i can see squalor, filth, garbage, poverty et al. around me and yet go about my work - thanks to bombay......i can get whatever i wnat whenever i want it - bombay affords me to do so......... negative things or positive is the way one looks at it.....bombay's made me cosmopolitan, tolerant of other cultures of varied backgrounds, helped me develop patience, helped me focus on my work...

yes....i do agree that bombay has sucked me in a race, but the time that i have is my own. what i chosse to do with bombay is mine.... bombay for me is a tool, an opportunity ith a million outlets for me to channelize my energies, focus on what matters to me the most. Will i get the same thing in other cities, maybe - maybe not.............. do i have cribs about bombay - well, me no.... but then bombay through my eyes is entirely different than bombay from anyone else's eyes.....

wuold i like to live in a place thats less crowded, where breathing fresh air is not a 3 hour drive and where i can know all the people i live with.....yes, i would.... the mountains, the solitude, the feeling of making a difference, yup, would love it.......

all in good time.............
your post was nice...made me think about bombay.... home....

Hermit Chords said...

@ Macha

"i can't speak a single language in its entire purity - bombay never demanded me to..."

That says so much. Life goes on, yes, but it only goes on, what is its quality?

Thanks for the comment. All said and done, if you genuinely think of Mumbai as home, that's quite a tribute to the city.

Anonymous said...

hey kaushik, how are you doing machan??! will read the post later in the evening to find out ... right now, i gotta prepare a report for lingu!!! - vinod sankar.

ps: you don't come online on yahoo messenger or something?? the instant messaging conversations (back then, we had sametime!) used to be eye openers!

Fellow Chaser said...

Attachment ..Have you ever thought of that word? We get attached with consummate ease to things animate, inanimate, dead and living, things which poke a hole in the rubric of our understanding and to things which propel us to a place in the sun. Yet can we / do we have the courage to step back and question our attachment to a place a thing or a person? Is that true freedom. I ask you ..Oh curious onlooker, so caught up in observing the very tenets of life in one microcosm that you call home and others call a destination! Is it possible for us to be unattached to the things we adore? It is a profound question, yet one I have a funny feeling you will consider replying to...cause i have left it there on the boundary wall of reason scrawled on the philosophers almost virgin tablet...Humor me!

Vidya said...

hmm.. interesting question by Fellow Chaser.. which was exactly what I thought after reading Atticus' post and yours ..

We are getting attached to animate and inanimate things.. and it seems inevitable. coz the brain wants to create a maya of happiness.. Hmm.. let me see if I can collect my thoughts on this and put up a post...

BTW I noticed that I am pretty attached to Chennai. I keep cribing about the heat, the roads, the culture et al. But it has become an inseparable part of me. And to think that any other place can take its place...well I dont know.. I think, heart of hearts,I will always be a chennai-ite :)

Hermit Chords said...

@fellow chaser

Well, certainly with attachment there's no freedom. Not just attachment to places or things or people, but identities, self-images, even thought and its trappings of conditioning.

Beauty is when there's freedom form attachement, and a sense of relationships around us, how networked things are. That happens sometimes even in urban spaces, when suddenly one stops and is aware of the rat scurrying under the drains, the drains spread out below the glittering city, the block with a thousand windows and a million preoccupations...

And then, is there really a distinction between the animate and the inanimate, between your consciousness and the snaking of an overfed local train?

Zeitgeist said...

For Attachment

In our quest for detachment,it's why's and wherefore's we forget to appreciate attachment as a natural basic human instinct rather than labelling it a 'weakness',and a foible best avoided..

Attachment conjures up rather vivd pictures i'll admit and perhaps cloaks all with the feeling of well being.(Perhaps that itself is it's very essence..)BUT it lends so much feeling,depth to a description that simply cannot be replicated by detachment..

In fact if i may say so,there is the thread of attachment running through this entire post..Right from the boy from the colony to people who make a choice.It speaks of someone who's lived them,touched them,who's experiences and perhaps even desicions have been shaped by one or more of the elements,either consiously or unconsiously.

So i will politely decline with the part about Fellow chaser's "courage...question attachment?" because in my perspective exhibiting attachment isn't about questioning one's threshold of weakness and Kaushik Ramu's "Beauty is when there is freedom from attachment" because beauty magnifies million fold when there is attachment.

As if to cite an instance,My friends fail to understand why I find Vasanthi,(a hawker girl who haunts the locals),phenomenally ravishing,even in her usual bright mismatched rags,holed blouses and dark skin..For me her clothes are "gypsy-ish",her skin "copper glazed",her waif like frame could even contend with the Crawford's and Campbell's sashaying down a Versace ramp..

It's all in the eyes of the beholder my friend.It's all in there.

Wild Reeds said...

Dear Hermit Chords,
Beautiful beautiful post. As a lifelong Bombay resident, and an occasional Bangalore visitor, your post had a nice deep resonance for me.
Keep it up!!

Hermit Chords said...

@ Wild Reeds

Thanks. I haven't been to the Bangalore I knew, in a long, long time...hence the nostalgia, methinks.

Hemang said...

Hi Kaushik

Such a wonderful blog....

Pure, innocent .. just like you.

Just may be - this is one of the best blogs i have read.

Keep writing,

U can spread happiness just by your writing

Hemang

bjkdy said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Hermit Chords said...

@ Hemang

Thanks buddy. I'm happy you liked it despite my cribbing tendencies :) See you soon for a long-due talk over chai, some time.

Kaushik.

Hermit Chords said...

@ Vidya

Waiting for your post, also for one on hideouts that you said you'd write :)

Take Care,

Kaushik

Seagull said...

Read your blog today after a very long time. "Amen" is all that I shall say :) Choices, for all the sweetness is the word "choice", are not easy to make aren't they. Neither for men, nor for cities.

Bombay Addict said...

Hey Kaushik - I've linked up to this post on my attempt at blogrolling bombay. Hope you don't mind. Thanks a lot.

Hermit Chords said...

:@ seagull

No my dear, they are not, and that's why we must return to the goodness of the earth instead of trying to maximise our GNP :)

K

Hermit Chords said...

@ bombay addict

Thanks. It should be nice, to have a Bombay blogroll than one can turn to from time time :)

Kaushik

Ph said...

Time to post, surely?

Hermit Chords said...

@ ph

yes it is :) thanks. i've been travelling and ...drifting

farah said...

Hi Kaushik,
Stumbled across your blog while I was looking for pictures of Smoker's Corner.
Smoker's corner is on DN Road. Just up the road from Bombay Stores (towards Ballard Pier). It's open from 10:30 - 7:00 from Monday to Saturday, except for bank holidays. It's brilliant, mostly second hand books, but in good conition. it's one of my favouite places in the city.
farah.

Anonymous said...

"The smell of filter coffee, fresh crisp Deccan Herald, Dravid, coffee in tinytot tumblers of steel at one-minute eateries, vans returning from the wholesale market, piled with fresh bargain vegetables for someone's wedding, and six little cousins craning out of the window" - all vignettes of a Bangalore that I love beyond compare.
Beautiful words and pictures here! The nicest thing that happened today was running into your blog. Headlong.

~ S.

Anonymous said...

Hi!

Looks as if I've come here almost 4 years too late. I was searching the web for blogs on Bombay, my first home. (I live in New York now!). And came across your post from some time ago on the Fort area. I used to live close by. My grandmother used to own one of those apartments in the faceless faded buildings on Marine Drive, and most of my evenings were spent taking walks in the city.I have many tender memories.

Your words are visually stirring. I ended up reading through everything, with a cup of hot chocolate by my side. It's warm weather, but somehow drinking chocolate goes well with the promise of comfort.

Why don't you write anymore? Or do you write some place else? Would love to keep reading.

Regards,

Anwesha

(anwesha_mistry@hotmail.com)